EP 149: Employee Handbook Must-Haves - Your Legal Shield (and What to Put In It)

Host: Kerri Roberts · Run time: ~29 minutes

🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts (https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/dont-waste-the-chaos/id1723388520) · Spotify (https://open.spotify.com/show/0nmxuIYEmqpbqZxzoxgiMY) · Buzzsprout (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2471085)

📺 Watch on YouTube: https://youtu.be/OqCqWbBUwL0?si=MqgqEjCtvXbeqe-4

📖 Read the full transcript below

Episode Summary

Your handbook is not a rule book. It’s the one document that protects the employer and the employee, and the law expects you to have one anyway. Most companies land in one of two spots. Either there’s no handbook at all and every rule lives in the owner’s head, or there’s an old template or a pile of 20 to 30 separate policies that don’t agree with each other. In both cases, decisions get made at game time based on whoever is standing in front of you, and that is how a discrimination claim gets started. In this episode, Kerri Roberts explains why policy has to be written before the situation happens, what has to be in a handbook (at-will language, an EEO and anti-harassment policy with a real complaint process, FMLA notice if you’re covered, and an acknowledgement), the template traps that can make common rules unlawful, and how to use AI to get a stronger first draft without inheriting outdated law. The handbook is cheap. The claim never is.

In This Episode

  • Why a handbook is a legal shield and not just a rule book

  • Why policy written before a problem is a clean decision, and policy written after looks like favoritism

  • How progressive discipline language with no at-will statement can be read as a contract

  • Why an anti-harassment policy with a working complaint procedure is the core of your defense

  • When federal and state laws kick in by headcount, from Missouri’s six employees to FMLA’s 50

  • Why the acknowledgement matters and how to do it electronically

  • How free templates and outdated AI answers can create unlawful rules

  • A prompt approach for using AI to draft or audit your handbook

Chapter Timestamps

0:00 Your handbook is a legal shield, not a rule book

2:16 Two spots most companies are in

4:41 Write the policy before you need it

7:00 The at-will disclaimer

9:19 EEO and anti-harassment policy with a real complaint process

10:15 FMLA and state leave laws

11:30 The acknowledgement

13:51 Why a free template can bite you

16:16 Missouri sick leave and keeping your template current

18:40 State specifics: Missouri Human Rights Act and final pay

20:59 The cost of getting it wrong

23:15 How to use AI to start your handbook

25:38 Your action item

Resources Mentioned

Your Action Item

This week, open your handbook, or the template you keep meaning to use, and find your at-will disclaimer if you’re in an at-will state. If it’s missing and you have progressive discipline in there, it can read like a contract. Put your state and situation into your AI tool and have it help you fix it, then have an attorney review it.

GET THE MONDAY EMAIL

If this episode resonated, you’ll like the Monday morning email. Every Monday at 5:28am, Kerri sends one practical idea for leaders who want to do this work better — including the conversations behind episodes like this one. 1,000+ leaders. 50%+ open rate. → https://saltandlight.myflodesk.com/saltandlightadvisors

Full Transcript

Why your handbook is a legal shield

Most people just view a handbook as a rule book, right? That’s usually the way we talk about it. It’s a way to keep employers out of trouble. But that is not the reality of a handbook, and it’s not why I preach why you need one. However, it is true that it helps you in the time of need as an employer, but it also helps the employee understand the expectations, which is why we are going to get deeper into it today. A handbook is the one document that protects you, whoever’s listening. You as the employee, you as the employer, both of you. It is essentially an understanding and agreement on what it looks like to be an employee at this organization. So you need one, and the law states that you need one anyway. So let’s make sure that the one that you’ve got is great.

We want to make sure you’ve got your at-will language in it. What happens if somebody just abandons their job for three days? What happens when they quit? If they have paid time off sitting in a bank, all of those good things. I want to show you what’s actually needing to be in there. And then I also want to address some of the biggest claims that come across my desk so I can help protect you a little bit.

So welcome back to another episode of Don’t Waste the Chaos. I’m your host, Kerri Roberts. I’ve been doing HR for well over 20 years and I started out in corporate. I worked in distribution, in finance, higher education, insurance, and then got into mergers and acquisitions before I ultimately went out on my own three and a half, four years ago. I started Salt and Light Advisors, which is an HR consulting firm focused on small to mid-sized businesses, building their HR foundation so they can run with it on their own. That has been a huge blessing to me. I’ve loved it.

I’ve been running this podcast the last couple of years. I launched January of 2024. I’ve put out an episode every single week since January of 2024, and I’m recording this episode the beginning of November 2026. I haven’t missed a week, haven’t missed a Tuesday. So there’s plenty of old content. If you’re listening to this and it’s your first episode, there’s a lot of content back there that you can dig into, and there are other episodes on handbooks too. I do get into HR law and compliance often, and you’re in the middle of a series on how to do HR law without an attorney.

That being said, I highly recommend that you do get an attorney. I am not an attorney. This is HR advice. It is important that you have an employment attorney. All of my clients do. Sometimes I’m just like, hey, you might want to run this by an attorney. I know what I’ve seen happen, I know what’s happening in the courts, but sometimes we’d like an attorney to sign off. I’ve got a sticky situation at a client right now and we’ve got an attorney engaged. Sometimes we need to, sometimes we don’t. So I am not your attorney. This is not legal advice. I say that to cover myself, but also to remind you that sometimes we need the legal expert, including an HR pro.

Where most companies are

So let’s get into today’s episode. A handbook is a legal shield. It’s not necessarily a rule book. However, there are rules in there, there are guides in there. There are a couple of ways to get this wrong as well, and I want to tackle as much as we possibly can in about 20 minutes today. I know after that I lose your attention because we’re talking about HR, and I understand that you all are actually trying to run your businesses. HR feels like another part-time job, which is why I exist in general. We’re going to keep this short and tight.

Most companies are in one of two spots. They either have no handbook at all when I come across them and every rule lives in the owner’s head, or somebody else’s. Or there’s a whole bunch of policies. I’ve got a couple of clients who, when I came to them, had a slew of policies their new hires would have to sign. I’m not exaggerating when I say between 20 and 30 individual policies when they started. And I’m just like, hey, this is a handbook, by the way. Let’s put this all in a handbook so we can get one acknowledgement. So clients are usually either in that spot, with an old template or all of these policies that aren’t congruent, or they don’t have a handbook at all. I’m curious where you’re sitting today. Hardly ever do I run across a client who’s like, yes, I’ve got an up-to-date handbook, we audit it annually, we make sure it’s in alignment with our current business practices. With my clients, it does happen. But in general, that doesn’t.

If every decision looks personal and inconsistent, meaning you have to come to the owner or a person on the leadership team and they’re making a game-time call based on the employee that’s standing in front of them, that is how a discrimination claim can get started. That’s why a systematic approach to these policies is super important. And if you’ve downloaded a template from AI, I’m not going to knock you on that. I’m going to give you some tips at the very end of this episode of what to put into AI so you can get a better template to get started with.

Write the policy before you need it

The handbook’s job is not to control people. It’s to prove in writing what the rules were before something went wrong. Because if we’re putting it into writing after something goes wrong, it looks like we’re making a call to get somebody out the door, or show favoritism, or discriminate. We want it written and documented before something goes wrong. That’s the name of the game. You want to have these guidelines so that if and when something comes up, you’ve got something to rely on versus emotions or your game-time decision. You write the policy before the situation happens, not after.

A no-call, no-show policy that says after three days of no contact that’s considered job abandonment, if that’s written down before it actually happens, it’s a clean termination. If it’s invented the day that you need it, a person could say you made that up to get rid of me. And if they’ve got any kind of Title VII claim, you just never know, then you’ve got a potential lawsuit, even though it’s a legitimate policy that you should have. If you didn’t have it written down, that’s a problem.

Same thing with the PTO payout rule, disciplinary action steps, social media policies, all of these things. Let’s say you let people go into arrears on their paid time off, and an employee quits and they are seven days in arrears. You’re like, I’ve got that documented, I’m going to take it out of their final paycheck. Do you mean you have it documented like you told the person you were going to take it out of their paycheck, or do you have it documented in a handbook and a policy that they acknowledged? Those are two very different things, and you can’t withhold earned compensation without that documented. That’s why we’re making it in advance. We don’t want a wage violation. We don’t want an oops in this situation. Guessing is exactly where that’s going to get you.

The at-will disclaimer

You also want to make sure that there are a number of things in there. You might be missing some of your day-to-day practices, and I’d rather they all be in there, but there are some things we cannot miss. This isn’t an exhaustive list, but here’s what I want to see you have right now. The first is your at-will disclaimer if you are in an at-will state. I practice a lot in Missouri. That’s where I live, and it’s an at-will state. Employees usually know that, so why do we have to put it in the handbook? Because if you put your disciplinary action process in the handbook, or a number of different things, it can insinuate a contract, guaranteed employment. If you don’t have an at-will statement inside your handbook, I have seen employees who deserved to get fired win a court case because of the way the handbook was written. This is why some people say, well, then I’m just not going to have one at all. That’s not the answer. Let’s make sure we have that at-will statement inside your handbook.

A handbook that promises progressive discipline or says people only get fired for cause, with no at-will language, can be read as a contract. Courts have done exactly this. The landmark case I was looking over before this episode was Toussaint versus Blue Cross in Michigan. So an at-will firing, which is totally fine to do, becomes a breach of contract lawsuit, which is what happened in that case, because your own handbook accidentally promised job security. You didn’t know that it did, but it did. The fix is simple: a clear at-will disclaimer and a signed acknowledgement. We’ll get more into the acknowledgement, but it doesn’t actually have to be wet ink. You can have this acknowledged by the last four digits of their Social Security number inside your HR payroll software, or a number of different things. We just need it acknowledged.

EEO, anti-harassment, and FMLA

The second one I want to see in there is your equal employment opportunity statement and your anti-harassment policy with a real complaint process. At 15 or more employees, federal anti-discrimination law like Title VII and the ADA applies to you. Age discrimination law kicks in at 20 or more employees. And here’s the one that pays for itself. The EEOC harassment guidance treats a written harassment policy plus a working complaint procedure as the core of your legal defense if a claim ever lands. No policy, no way to report it, and you can lose the defense before you even start, even if the claim is a stretch. That’s not a poster on the wall. That’s the line between a claim you can defend and a settlement you just have to write a check for. So we want to make sure we’ve got those policies in the handbook, our managers understand them, our employees have acknowledged them, and we’re following those processes, which is a huge part of the handbook as well.

FMLA is another one I want to see if you’re big enough. At 50 or more employees within 75 miles, the Family and Medical Leave Act applies, and if you’re covered and you have a handbook, the FMLA general notice has to be inside of it. If you have under 50, FMLA doesn’t apply federally, but don’t assume you’re off the hook, because state leave laws reach much smaller employers. You need to know what your state leave laws are, and if you’ve been listening to this series, sometimes there are even county or city laws you have to pay attention to. Make sure you’re tracking all of that.

The acknowledgement

An acknowledgement page is another piece. You don’t necessarily have to have a page unless you’re literally printing it off and having them sign, and I don’t recommend that. It’s harder to track, and then you have to keep paper files, or you’re printing it off, they’re signing it, you’re scanning it back in. I don’t know why people are still doing that in 2026. Please stop. Let’s make this easier. But we do need at least an electronic acknowledgement inside that HR payroll system. If you don’t have an HR payroll system, use Adobe Sign, DocuSign, something like that, so they can sign electronically, and then make sure that is stored in the employee file somewhere. If you’re in an HR payroll system, it will automatically store in the employee file. The acknowledgement is: I received it and I read it. It doesn’t have to say I agree and I love everything that it says. It’s I’m acknowledging I have access to this handbook, it has been given to me. Otherwise you can’t prove that they ever had it.

Why a free template can bite you

Now let’s talk about templates. I am not mad if you are using a template. My life’s desire is not to write your handbook for you. That’s actually one of my least favorite things to do for clients, but it’s something I end up doing for almost every single client, because if they don’t have one it has to be written, and if they do have one and it’s not very good we’ve got to revamp it. I just can’t express how underwhelming it is to do this process, but it’s important.

This is why a template is tough. You can start out using a template. I’m totally fine with that. That’s better than nothing. But if you don’t actually practice what you preach in that handbook, no one’s going to be like, well, it was a template, so I can’t hold them to that. That’s your handbook. You are going to be held to it. So you have to make sure it aligns with the way you do business. This is where a free download can really bite you.

I just saw some data. In 2023 the National Labor Relations Board set a standard in the Stericycle decision that made common handbook rules presumptively unlawful if an employee could read them as discouraging them from talking to coworkers about pay or working conditions. We already know there was a law that said you could talk about pay, but if your handbook makes it sound like you can’t, that’s a whole other issue. I’ve had clients where I said, hey, your handbook makes it sound like they can’t talk about their pay, and they said, well, I don’t want them to talk about their pay. I’m like, well, that’s illegal for you to put in the handbook. And if I’m an employee and I get fired, I’m going to say they had illegal stuff in their handbook, so I didn’t want to follow anything in it, and the judge is probably going to say, cool, I’m going to rule with you, because that employer should know better. So you have to make sure your handbook is written in an appropriate way, and AI can’t always pick that up. It can get you pretty far down the road. You just want to be sure. Don’t-discuss-your-salary rules, overly broad confidentiality language, and overly punitive social media rules can all be unlawful.

It’s genuinely in flux. The board is being rebuilt in 2026, and some things might change. Not a lot of decisions have come out of it so far, but I anticipate some changes coming from the NLRB. When new boards are built, they sometimes overturn past decisions. A few standards are expected to roll back, but don’t quote me on that. We’ll see what ends up happening.

Missouri sick leave and keeping your template current

Think about this. If you’re in the state of Missouri, you probably know about this, and other states have had things like this happen as well. In 2024, Missouri voters passed a mandate that you had to have mandatory sick leave as an employer. In my opinion, I’m very employee friendly, but that makes it an undue hardship on the employer to track. When you have separate sick leave and an employee doesn’t use it, they feel like they’re losing a benefit you’ve given them. When it washes out at the end of the year, it’s usually use it or lose it, and that employee feels like they miss out on a benefit that other people took advantage of. It causes bitterness, and it also causes lying. I’m not mad at an employee for wanting to use the benefits given to them, but it almost encourages dishonesty. I know that might sound like a stretch, but I’ve seen it time and time again. So I recommend one leave bank. But that law passed, and I was like, gosh, here we go, we’re going back to the old days of all these separate banks. I got in touch with all my clients, we got it all set up, HR payroll systems were running around making sure it was set up, and by the time it was implemented we knew it was already going to get rolled back. That was just a mess. That stuff happens, though. As soon as that got passed I was like, this is not going to last, everyone’s going to fight it. And Governor Kehoe signed the repeal and it got brought back.

So the tip is, if you use a template, you’ve got to be checking on it very regularly. You can’t just set it and forget it. I like to take a look at the handbook every year and make sure it’s still in alignment with state and federal laws. I know so many of you are like, I don’t have time for that. Well, I tell you what, I’ve been sued a handful of times at different employers over the years, age discrimination, racial discrimination, different things. If you do not have your documentation in a row, it’s going to take up so much time. One case took almost a year, another took around eight months, and another took only 12 days, not 12 months, because I had all of my ducks in a row and that person was just mad. I’ve seen it go all different directions. If you don’t have all of your documentation, it takes much longer to fight and you usually end up settling, which means money and an implied admission of wrongdoing, even if you didn’t do wrong. So I recommend you have your documents in place.

State specifics: Missouri

I mentioned that Missouri is an at-will state earlier. A handbook promising progressive disciplinary action is exactly what will undo your whole situation. The Missouri Human Rights Act covers employers with six or more employees, not 15. We talked earlier about 15 for Title VII and the ADA. Six in the state of Missouri. So you can be too small for federal discrimination law and still be fully covered in Missouri. And in Missouri, like a lot of states, final pay is due at the time of dismissal if the employee asks for it. You have to present that money right then, so you have to be prepared for that.

Let’s say you don’t pay someone on their way out the door and they ask for it, and your payroll person’s already gone for the day and nobody else can write a check. First of all, you should have backups. Somebody else should be able to do that, not just one person. That’s a different episode, but do not be held hostage by one employee. If that happens, you need to get that check to that employee overnight, ASAP, and by the time they file suit they’ll already have the check, so it won’t go anywhere, but you could still get a fine. Do you have to have the paycheck queued up? No, you don’t. I usually tell employers you can just say your next paycheck will be direct deposited as usual on X date with your final insurance premiums taken out of it, and work it into your normal process. For most people that’s fine, but every once in a while somebody requests it and you are on the hook to give it.

I’m giving you some examples of state-specific laws to remind you that you need to make sure you’re following federal, state, and then city and county. I used to live in Columbia, Missouri, and Columbia has a couple of unique things. St. Louis has a couple of unique things. So pay attention to that.

The cost of getting it wrong

If you listen to my show very often, you know I’m always going to tell you that HR metrics are finance metrics. There are dollars involved. I did a little research. In fiscal year 2024 the EEOC recovered nearly $700 million for workers, a record year. The anti-harassment policy you didn’t write is the legal defense you cannot use. The at-will language you skipped is a breach of contract claim you now have to settle. $700 million is what the EEOC collected on behalf of employees against employers. You don’t want to be a line in that number because your handbook had a hole in it. That’s where I see a lot of things happen. The handbook is cheap, the claim never is.

This is the foundation. The culture stuff, the swag, the parties, all of that is the roof. You can’t call it culture when the paycheck’s wrong and the handbook doesn’t exist, because your culture is actually a mess then. You’re just not a reliable and trustworthy employer without it. I hate to say it, but that’s the reality. This is the pay-to-play, the basic blocking and tackling. We’ve got to have our policies. I don’t care how cool you are or how amazing a family culture you have or how careful you are with who you hire. It’s going to happen to you. I’ve seen it over and over again.

Using AI to start your handbook

When I build a handbook for a client, I don’t start with a template. Here are some AI tips. If you don’t have a handbook right now, I’m not telling you this is going to be perfectly legally compliant, but it’s a really good start. Type into your AI, whether you’re using ChatGPT, Claude, whatever you’re using: I am an employer in X industry. I operate in X state. I have remote employees in X state and X state. I pay biweekly, monthly, whatever. I have this many employees. We have this PTO. I like to hit the mic button to record and just start talking about your organization. Our mission, vision, and values are this. These are our non-negotiables for our employees. These are the days we take off for holidays that we pay our staff. We have medical insurance. Just start talking and then say, will you write me the beginning of a handbook? Ask me what questions you need to ask me to make sure the handbook is robust. Make sure you’re including all required policies, federal and state. I also operate out of X County, so make sure that’s covered, and the cities and counties where any employees may sit if they’re remote.

AI is genuinely good at catching missing procedures, like if you don’t have a complaint procedure, and it’s pretty good at catching discipline language that reads like a contract. So either take your old handbook, load it, tell it some about yourself and ask it to do an audit for you, or start from scratch. It’s going to get you pretty far.

AI doesn’t know when it’s quoting an old Missouri law, though. I have had that paid sick leave issue when I’m putting stuff into AI. It continues to say it needs a separate sick leave bank, and every time I’m like, you are wrong, that got overturned, and it’ll say, you got me there, you’re right. So you’ve got to be careful. I love AI, I talk about it all the time, but it might pull certain websites and quote something old, so you have to know what you’re talking about. That’s why you need a pro. I draft with AI, then I verify every policy against current law, your actual state, and I own the final call with you. We work on it together, especially the at-will language and anything that could become a contract. AI can write the rough draft. The law, me and you own the final one.

If you just realized you’ve got a template you downloaded in 2022 or older and you don’t have some of these policies at all, it’s not a character flaw. You’ve just been too busy running the business and the paperwork that protects it is kind of missing. The good news is that a handbook is one of the most learnable pieces of HR out there. You can absolutely build it yourself if you want to DIY it.

Resources and your action item

I’ve got my coursework at saltandlightadvisors.com/resources. Specifically for handbooks, you’d want my HR Foundations course. I have three courses: HR Foundations, Strategic HR, and HR Operating System. In Foundations is where you’ll find the HR law, your employer responsibilities, and the laws around hiring and onboarding. Of course, you can always do my free mini HR audit just to get you started. It’s about 10 questions, it’s pretty quick, and it will give you a score on whether you need some attention, you’re in a risky spot, or you have a solid foundation. You can find it at saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit. And if you’re like, actually I know this is a mess and I don’t have time to deal with it, we can always talk about consulting. I have a couple of openings coming available at the beginning of 2027. I’m booked for the rest of 2026, so the free resources and the coursework are the best way to start, or my book, The HR Easy Button, which covers a ton of the HR law, hiring, onboarding, and employer responsibilities. It’s on Amazon and on my website, softback, hardback, Audible.

So this week, this is what I want you to do. Open up your handbook if you have it, or the template you kept meaning to use, and find the at-will disclaimer if you’re in an at-will state. If it’s not there and you’ve got progressive discipline in there, it’s going to look like a contract and you need to get that figured out ASAP. Throw it back into your AI and say, I am in the state of X, we’re an at-will state, can you get this fixed for me? That’s your starting point.

Next week we stay right in the danger zone and move on to hiring: the interview questions that can quietly get you sued and what you legally cannot ask a candidate. You’re not going to want to miss that one.

Closing

Listen, I know that sometimes these aspects of HR can feel like a second job, but it’s what sets you apart as an employer. This is a part of your culture. So many of us want to look at learning and development, or what swag we’re giving our people, or what our building looks like. All of those things matter too. But if you aren’t legally sound and compliant and a trustworthy employer, your culture is crap. Let’s say you’re in a marriage and you can’t trust each other, but you’re both really good looking. That’s the reality of it. We don’t want it to just look good on the outside. We want it to actually be healthy and functioning and non-toxic on the inside. I know that can feel like chaos, but the work is worth it. So don’t waste the chaos. Embrace it. I hope I see you back next week, and don’t forget to hit subscribe.

Resources To Keep Building

If your handbook has holes in it, take the free HR Audit to see where your people systems stand and what to fix first. → saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit

Resources to keep building:

🎯 Take the free HR Audit — Score your HR systems in 5 minutes and see exactly where your gaps are. 👉 saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit

🎙️ Listen to Don’t Waste the Chaos — This episode: 👉 https://youtu.be/OqCqWbBUwL0?si=MqgqEjCtvXbeqe-4

📚 Explore the HR coursework — Self-paced courses, tools, and resources to build your HR systems step by step. 👉 saltandlightadvisors.com/resources

✉️ Get the Monday Email — One practical idea for leaders, every Monday at 5:28am. 1,000+ leaders, 50%+ open rate. 👉 saltandlight.myflodesk.com/saltandlightadvisors

Need fractional HR support or want to talk through a specific challenge? 👉 saltandlightadvisors.com/contact

Next
Next

EP 148: 1099 vs W-2 - How to Tell If Your Contractor Is Really an Employee | HR Law Without an Attorney