EP 131: Leadership Development for Small Business - The Skills No One Teaches Your Managers | HR Systems Series
Episode Summary
Most small businesses promote their best individual contributor into a leadership role - and then act surprised when things fall apart. Here’s why: being excellent at the work doesn’t make someone excellent at leading people in the work. They’re two completely different skill sets, and almost no one teaches the second. We train people to do the job. We don’t train people to lead the people doing the job. In this episode of Don’t Waste the Chaos, Kerri Roberts breaks down what leadership development actually looks like at a small or mid-sized business - the six skills every manager needs, the four ways new managers fail, and how to build a real leadership development program with no training budget at all.
Drawing on 20+ years in HR and her own climb from individual contributor to COO and CMO, Kerri makes the case that most HR chaos - bad hiring, failed onboarding, performance problems, discipline drama - lives and dies at the manager level. Leadership development is the multiplier: build your managers well and everything else in your HR foundation gets stronger. You don’t need a corporate training program. You need intentional, consistent investment in the people who lead your people.
In This Episode
• Why your best salesperson, technician, or admin so often becomes a struggling manager - and why “they figured it out elsewhere” is a myth
• The real difference between individual-contributor success (personal output) and manager success (team output, developing others)
• The four most common new-manager failure modes - and how to spot them on your team
• The six core skills every manager needs: clear expectations, feedback that lands, hard conversations, real delegation, useful one-on-ones, and managing their own triggers
• How most managers manage the way they were managed - and how to break the cycle on purpose
• A four-level leadership development program you can run for little to no money
• How leadership development plus workforce planning equals your real succession plan
• The one conversation you can have this week that could change an employee’s career
Chapter Timestamps
0:00 Why Your Best Employee Becomes a Struggling Manager
2:17 Where Leadership Development Fits in Your HR Foundation
4:37 The Promotion Problem
7:01 The 4 New-Manager Failure Modes
9:21 “Nobody Ever Taught Me”: Breaking the Cycle
11:33 Skill 1 - Set Clear Expectations
13:51 Skill 2 - Give Feedback That Lands
16:17 Skill 3 - Have the Hard Conversations
18:40 Skill 4 - Delegate Without Dumping
20:54 Skill 5 - Run a Useful One-on-One
22:00 Skill 6 - Manage Your Own Triggers
23:16 A Leadership Program With No Training Budget (4 Levels)
32:34 Your Leadership Pipeline & Succession Plan
34:53 Your Action Item This Week
Resources Mentioned
• The HR Easy Button (book): saltandlightadvisors.com/thehreasybutton - paperback, hardback, and Kindle on Amazon
• HR Foundations course (under $100): saltandlightadvisors.com/hrfoundations
• HR Operating System course: saltandlightadvisors.com/hroperatingsystem
• Strategic coursework (releasing August 2026): saltandlightadvisors.com/resources
• Free Mini HR Audit: saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit
• Book a deep-dive HR audit / gap analysis: saltandlightadvisors.com/contact
• Related episodes: the Performance Management episode (SBI and COIN frameworks, one-on-one structure), the Workforce Planning episode (succession planning), and the Metrics episode
Episodes in the HR Systems Series
This episode is part of the 13-part HR Systems Series, where Kerri walks through the full HR foundation from her book, The HR Easy Button - across the foundational, operational, and strategic levels.
• Earlier in the series: hiring, onboarding, policies, performance management, leave management, metrics, and workforce planning
• Leadership Development (you’re here)
• Culture & Engagement (coming next week)
• HR Tech & Systems (coming soon)
Your Action Item
Name one person on your team who has management potential right now - and schedule a conversation with them this week to tell them you see it. It sounds simple, but it can be life-changing. They’ll leave that conversation feeling seen and valued, and it can reinvigorate their commitment to your business. Everything in your HR foundation runs through your managers, so investing in the next one - before you need them - is one of the strongest retention moves you have.
GET THE MONDAY EMAIL
If this episode resonated, you’ll like the Monday morning email. Every Monday at 5:28am, Kerri sends one practical idea for leaders who want to do this work better - including the conversations behind episodes like this one. 1,000+ leaders. 50%+ open rate. Subscribe: saltandlight.myflodesk.com/saltandlightadvisors
Full Transcript
Why Your Best Employee Becomes a Struggling Manager
Most small businesses promote their best individual contributor into a leadership role, and then they are surprised when things fall apart. Why is that? Being excellent at the work does not mean that we are going to be excellent at leading people in the work. It’s just, unfortunately, not a given, and not everyone wants to do it. They’re two completely different skill sets. And usually no one’s teaching the second.
We teach people how to do the job. We don’t teach people how to lead people who are doing the job. And that’s what we’re talking about today. One of the most common mistakes I see in business, especially small business, is great employee and then a terrible manager. They had no idea they needed to be different between doing the task and leading the task. We just didn’t teach them. Most HR chaos I see ties back to that: we never taught them to lead. Welcome back to Don’t Waste the Chaos. I’m your host, Kerri Roberts, and I’ve been doing this HR thing for over 20 years.
Where Leadership Development Fits in Your HR Foundation
You are catching me in the middle of a 13-part series. I’ve been going through the foundation of HR - essentially all the content I wrote in my book, The HR Easy Button. I’ve broken it into three areas. We’ve got our foundational level: hiring, onboarding, policies. Then our operational level, where we live day-to-day: performance management, leave management. Now we’re in the strategic realm. We’ve gone over metrics and workforce planning. Now we’re getting into leadership development. We’ll get into engagement and culture and even some HR tech aspects after this episode.
Everything we’ve covered so far in this series - bad hiring, failed onboarding, performance management gone wrong, discipline, chaos - most of it lives and dies at the manager level. So this right here, leadership development, is the multiplier system. We build the foundation and then we multiply our strength, because we’ve got a good management system. The HR Foundations and HR Operating System courses are available now, and the book is on Amazon - all at saltandlightadvisors.com/resources. The strategic coursework releases in August 2026, and the courses are all under a hundred dollars.
The Promotion Problem
We’ve got a solid performer. Your best salesperson becomes your sales manager. Your best technical employee becomes your team lead. Your best admin becomes your office manager. This happens in small business and in corporate. We give them a title change, maybe a raise, but zero development - literally zero. And then six months later, we’re wondering why we’re not getting the results we wanted.
Just because they were a good employee does not mean they know how to be a good manager. I don’t even care if they’ve managed elsewhere. We need a manager development program. The individual-contributor-to-manager transition is the hardest transition I’ve seen, and I’ve done it - individual contributor, supervisor, manager, director, VP, COO, CMO. Every transition is hard. Individual-contributor success is personal: personal output, personal performance, personal expertise. Manager success is team output, developing others, and creating conditions for good performance. Two completely different skill sets, and everything that made them great in the first job can work against them in the second.
The 4 New-Manager Failure Modes
Here are the four most common new-manager failure modes I’ve seen in 20 years in HR. First, they’re still doing the work they did before instead of leading it, because they can’t let go of the individual-contributor role. Second, they avoid hard conversations because they used to be peers - sometimes with people who have more tenure - so they feel nervous stepping on toes. Third, they manage personalities but not processes; they know their team, but they’re not building standard operating procedures, and that gets messy. Fourth, they set unclear expectations for their direct reports, because no one ever set clear expectations for them.
“Nobody Ever Taught Me”: Breaking the Cycle
I’ve had over a hundred people say to me, “No one ever taught me. I just figured it out.” I was at dinner with the leadership team of a mortgage company recently, and it was, “Why can’t these people just figure it out? I figured it out.” And I’m like, well, you’re in a leadership role for a reason, and they’re not. They’re not you. They likely have never been trained. Saying “I figured it out, so they need to figure it out” is not good leadership. And the employee is frustrated too, because you’re not setting clear expectations.
Here’s what nobody says out loud: most managers are managing the way they were managed, for better or worse. If you came up under a micromanager, you’re probably micromanaging - or you swung hard the other way, which isn’t healthy either. If you came up under someone who avoids conflict, you’re probably avoiding conflict. You break the cycle by giving people something different to model - by creating a program they can sit inside of so they understand their expectations. You don’t get better managers by telling them to step up. You get better managers by building a system for developing them.
So let’s talk about the core skills every manager needs - six things I see specifically in small to mid-sized businesses, though they’re translatable everywhere. They don’t have to do them perfectly, but they need to do them consistently, enough that their team can trust the process. So much of trust hinges on self-trust and self-confidence - we’ve proven to ourselves by putting in the reps, and then our team can trust us because we show up with consistency.
Skill 1 - Set Clear Expectations
Translate business goals into individual role clarity. If you’re a manager and you don’t even know the goals for your role, go have a conversation with the owner. Every employee should be able to answer: What am I responsible for? How will I be measured? What does success or failure look like in my role? If they can’t, the manager hasn’t done their job yet. And don’t just say it once or put it in a document - live by it every day.
Skill 2 - Give Feedback That Lands
Feedback people can understand and actually act on. We’ve talked about SMART goals; in the performance episode I went over SBI. We’re talking specific, behavior-focused, timely, and private feedback - giving it in a team setting won’t build trust. Role-play it with your managers, script it out, give them an outline like SBI or COIN. And here’s the thing: your employee is not mad if you follow a script. If you say, “We’re following a new process because we want our feedback to actually be helpful,” they’ll feel treated fairly. Practice on the small things - attendance, reliability - so you’ve got confidence when something is high-stakes.
Skill 3 - Have the Hard Conversations
Feedback isn’t always a hard conversation. Sometimes you just say, “Next time, can we do it differently?” Sometimes you have to say, “It’s not working” - that’s harder. The discipline conversation, the performance check-in, the “this isn’t working” conversation. Most managers avoid these because they were never taught how to have them - you can tell, because they don’t even have them at home. Give them an outline and a script. The conversation gets less scary when there’s a structure to follow.
Skill 4 - Delegate Without Dumping
Delegate with clarity: what needs to be done, by what timeline, to what standard, and with what authority. Then set the stage - tee up conversations, send a few emails, pave the way. Don’t throw people to the wolves. The manager who can’t delegate is the bottleneck, and they’re usually burning out quietly. Good delegation develops the team; poor delegation just creates more chaos - and then you’re either not following up, or you are and they’re frustrated, because you didn’t delegate well in the first place.
Skill 5 - Run a Useful One-on-One
I know we all want fewer meetings, but one-on-ones with every direct report are non-negotiable. We don’t skip them, we don’t push them. These aren’t status updates - they’re a relationship and accountability conversation that stays on the calendar. Don’t show up saying, “Got anything for me? I don’t really have anything for you.” Have an agenda. In the performance episode I shared the monthly structure: an accountability check-in, a workload review, real-time feedback, and a forward focus on what’s due before next time. Capture notes (or let AI do it) so you can follow up - and so your annual reviews aren’t built on recency bias.
Skill 6 - Manage Your Own Triggers
Stress, frustration, favoritism, reactivity - we can’t let those flow down to the team. It should roll uphill: take your frustrations to your own leader, not your subordinates. Those people aren’t paid to absorb your issues. Self-awareness is foundational - everything else is built on it. There’s a saying that hurt people hurt people, and helped people help people. So get help if you need it. We can’t fully develop this for our managers, but we can build a culture where it’s expected and modeled at the top.
A Leadership Program With No Training Budget (4 Levels)
People say, “We don’t have budget for this.” You don’t need a corporate training program - you need intentional, consistent investment in the people who lead your team. The investment doesn’t have to cost much; it just has to be consistent.
Level one - manager onboarding. If you have nothing, start here. When someone becomes a manager, treat it like a new hire. Document your management philosophy and how you actually handle the real situations: a raise request, a pregnancy or leave conversation, a death in someone’s family, a reliability problem, team drama. You’re already handling these - memorialize it. A quick way to start: put a monthly manager meeting on the calendar, walk through “What do we do when this happens?”, and document it into an SOP. Don’t promote another manager until you have a manager onboarding program.
Level two - regular manager development. If we want managers to be consistent with their people, we have to be consistent with them. Monthly or quarterly manager meetings - not just production numbers, but “How’s your team? What’s hard right now? What policy is unclear?” Share a book, an article, a podcast. Normalize continuous learning.
Level three - coaching and feedback for managers. Managers aren’t exempt from the performance system. If an employee thinks their manager never gets feedback, that’s disheartening - and no, your managers aren’t perfect (based on the calls I get every day, I promise). Skip-level conversations help. My favorite tool is a 360-degree review: peers, direct reports, and the manager’s leader all weigh in. I whitewash the comments so no one can be tracked down, look for key themes, and we deliver it together.
Level four - stretch assignments. This is NOT giving someone the title and responsibility without the pay until they “prove it” for six months - that’s not development, and it’s not legal. It’s giving emerging leaders small chances to lead before a full management role: lead a project, facilitate a meeting, mentor a new hire. That’s how you build the muscle - and your internal pipeline - before you need it. Start with manager onboarding and build from there.
Your Leadership Pipeline & Succession Plan
Workforce planning tells you what roles you’ll need and when. Leadership development tells you who can grow into them. Together, that’s your succession plan - and you need one for every role. Sort your pipeline into three tiers: who’s ready now, who could be ready in six to twelve months, and who has long-term potential. Then have the conversation. Don’t make it implicit, and don’t make someone seem like the “heir to the throne.” The next time you see a spark in someone, tell them: “I see this in you. Here’s where I’d love to see you grow.” Give them a simple gap analysis. Knowing you’re investing in their growth is one of the strongest retention tools you have.
Your Action Item This Week
Name one person on your team with management potential right now, and schedule a conversation this week to tell them you see it. It seems simple, but it could change their life - they’ll feel seen and valued, and it’ll reinvigorate their commitment. It all runs through your managers. If you want to go deeper on all 13 topics, head to saltandlightadvisors.com/resources. If you don’t know where to start, take the free mini HR audit at saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit, or reach out at saltandlightadvisors.com/contact for a deep-dive gap analysis. Next week: culture and engagement. Friends, the work is worth it. So don’t waste the chaos. Embrace it.
Resources To Keep Building
If you’ve just promoted a great employee into a management role - or you’re about to - take the free HR Audit to see whether your people systems are actually set up to support them. Score your HR systems in 5 minutes: saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit
Take the free HR Audit: saltandlightadvisors.com/hraudit
Explore the HR coursework: saltandlightadvisors.com/resources
Get the Monday Email: saltandlight.myflodesk.com/saltandlightadvisors
Need fractional HR support or want to talk through a specific challenge? saltandlightadvisors.com/contact
